Il Castagnolo

A country house B&B among olive trees in the hills near San Gimignano, with a small pool, breakfast buffet and Tuscan-style rooms.

Why people love it

• Peace and quiet. Most 2026 reviews describe a quiet setting among olive trees, about a 10-minute drive from San Gimignano.
• The staff. Guests say the staff are attentive. A late arrival was given a platter of food, and another guest was moved at once to a different room when theirs had a problem.
• Breakfast. Reviewers call the spread excellent and good value.
• The pool. A small, charming pool is mentioned in several reviews.

Why they come back

"This is now our third stay at this beautiful place. As always, the welcome is exemplary."

The worst thing guests say

Cleanliness comes up in recent reviews. In November 2025 two guests reported dirty showers, creaking beds and other flaws, in June 2026 a guest found the cleaning lacking and the bathroom awkward, and in August 2026 a guest had a clogged shower drain and a bad road to the parking lot. In April 2025 a family said a short-notice cancellation was refused. Earlier complaints from 2018 to 2024 also mention dirt.

Insider tips

• Driving is needed, and the road down to the parking is rough.
• There is no dinner on site.
• Check your room and shower on arrival and ask for another if there is a problem.

How we rated this: Google rating 4.5 from 347 reviews. We read the newest and the lowest-rated guest reviews (22 recent guest reviews with text) and set aside reviews from restaurant or bar visitors who did not stay. Address: SP1, 1 Loc. Castagnolo, 53037 San Gimignano SI.